WordPress WooCommerce Themes

Upgrading sludge drying beds without a mandatory centrifuge

Upgrading sludge drying beds without a mandatory centrifuge

Editorial material by Tymur Lievda, based on the work of Anatolii Mykhailovych Demchenko

Making use of existing structures

The DEMKUL trials used the sludge drying beds, drainage wells and the solution preparation and feed unit that were already in place. This is a concrete advantage for a utility that has suitable infrastructure and is considering upgrading it. [1, 2]

Reagent-based water separation in such a scheme does not require a centrifuge or press. Pumps, dosing, drainage maintenance and sludge removal remain part of the process. So it is fair to speak of the potential to reduce the need for a separate mechanical unit, not of zero energy use.

Comparison with international practice

In the study by Mamais et al., mechanical systems were assessed on dewatering and sludge disposal taken together. The centrifuge produced a drier cake, and its total cost at the plants studied was lower than that of the belt press. This shows that more expensive or more energy-intensive equipment does not always mean a more expensive complete scheme. [3]

The argument for DEMKUL is the possibility of using a bed that is already available. For a site with no free land, or one that requires fast, continuous sludge removal, a mechanical system may have the advantage.

What to include in the economic assessment

The reports forecast an increase in the load on the beds of at least five and seven times. These values should be presented as the authors’ forecasts, not as confirmed long-term performance.

For a water utility to make a decision, it needs to compare capital investment, reagent, electricity, labor, land, treatment of the discharged water and onward transport per tonne of dry solids. Such a calculation will show whether DEMKUL’s infrastructure advantage translates into financial savings.

Surface of bed No. 7 after loading began. Photo from A. M. Demchenko’s report. Date: 22.09.2014.

Sources

  1. Demchenko A. M. Report on industrial trials of the sewage sludge dewatering technology (in Ukrainian). NDC FARMADEM LLC and Chernihivvodokanal municipal enterprise, 2014. File “Демкул_отчет_1.doc”.
  2. Demchenko A. M. Report on industrial trials in the autumn–winter period (in Ukrainian). NDC FARMADEM LLC and Chernihivvodokanal municipal enterprise, 2014. File “Демкул_отчет_2.doc”.
  3. Mamais D. et al. Evaluation of different sludge mechanical dewatering technologies. Journal of Residuals Science & Technology, 2009, 6, 27–34.

First article in the series

Previous article · Next article

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

Don't forget to share